Archive note: The original lead image could not be recovered.
Archive note: Authorship attributed by the Prabhjot Singh archive. The original publication does not display a verified individual byline.
The Punjab Government once again finds itself in an embarrassing situation. As a sequel to the widening rift between Punjab Raj Bhavan and the Chief Ministers’ Secretariat, an eminent Doctor has refused to be part of this ongoing tussle.
Dr Gurpreet Singh Wander, an eminent cardiologist, has withdrawn his candidature for the post of Vice-Chancellor, Baba Farid Medical University.
The development is a sad reflection on the governance of this trouble-torn and controversy-ridden State.
Earlier, Dr Raj Bahadur, a world-renowned orthopaedic surgeon, refused to pocket the humiliation meted out to him by the Punjab Health Minister. Instead, he preferred to quit as Vice-Chancellor of Baba Farid Medical University.
Now it is the turn of Dr Gurpreet Singh Wander to find himself in a piquant situation with the Governor refusing to approve his appointment as a successor to Dr Raj Bahadur.
Governor Banwari Lal Purohit pointed out the circumvention of the procedure in making the appointment. The Chief Minister had announced Dr Wander’s appointment on September 30.
Punjab Raj Bhavan, however, took exception to the procedure adopted by the Punjab Government and reverted the file saying that a panel of three names be sent to him for final approval of a name for the coveted post of Vice-Chancellor. Constitutionally, the Governor happens to be the Chancellor of Baba Farid University.
This is the latest in the growing list of discord between Raj Bhavan and the Chief Ministers’ Secretariat. It has already taken a heavy toll and smeared the name of the State.
When discords outnumber accords, conflicts start. Conflicts are invariably detrimental to the health of a liberal democracy. They are not only a diversion from the core issues of a State or its people but also at times lead to disastrous consequences.
Punjab has been gradually growing towards an avoidable conflict. Starting with the refusal of permission to hold a special one-day session of Punjab Vidhan Sabha for seeking a vote of confidence, the discord between Raj Bhavan and the Chief Ministers’ Secretariat has been growing with every passing day.
Caught in the crossfire between Raj Bhavan and the Chief Ministers’ Secretariat is the academic institution of the Vice-Chancellor. After the humiliating experience of the previous Vice-Chancellor, Dr Raj Bahadur, his successor, Dr Gurpreet Singh Wander, too, has been caught in an unsavoury controversy. He decided to put an end to his own humiliation by opting out of the race. The loss is of the State and Baba Farid University.
Though Dr Wander, an eminent cardiologist, has nothing to do with the unsavoury conflict in the top echelons of the State, it has hurt him.
In less than two months, both these heads have been face to face with each other over totally avoidable issues. Needless to reiterate that in a democracy, the elected Government has the ultimate say. But that does not mean that honour and prestige of the office of the Governor can ever be compromised.
After withdrawal of permission to hold the session, the discord started snowballing into a conflict.
Legal advisers on both sides, instead of working for a ceasefire, gave opinions that led to distancing between the Constitutional head and the elected head of the State.
In the present case, Governor Banwarilal Purohit had returned the file with the comments that “proper procedure has not been followed”.
The matter is seen as an administrative lapse on part of the state government.
The procedure requires a scrutiny committee to check the eligibility of candidates before a search-cum-selection committee, headed by the Chief Secretary and other experts, shortlists a panel of three candidates for sending it to the Governor for clearance.
After the Vidhan Sabha fiasco, the rift grew wider with the Governor taking exception to the CM’s absence at the reception held in honour of President Droupadi Murmu at Punjab Raj Bhavan.
The President had come to Chandigarh to attend among others a special Air Force jubilee celebrations function. She also presided over the convocation of Punjab Engineering College.
The CM Bhagwant Mann cited his pre-commitments to miss the President’s felicitation. Instead, he deputed a team of Cabinet Ministers to represent him. Going by traditions and conventions, the CM was required to be present at a function held in the honour of the Constitutional head of the country, the President. Other functions, irrespective of their importance or significance, had to be either rescheduled or attended by other Cabinet Minister (s) as deputed by the Chief Minister.
The Governor had a point in stating that constitutional obligations have to be met on such occasions.
Whatever be the reasons, little or no effort is being made for a rapprochement between the Constitutional head and the elected head of the trouble-torn cash-strapped Punjab. The growing discords, if not checked, may lead to conflicts that would prove detrimental to the overall health of the State.
Archived copy of the original page: Wayback Machine

No comments yet
Comments are closed.